Cream Cheese Stuffed Mini Peppers

Cream Cheese Stuffed Mini Peppers is an easy appetizer made with 6 simple ingredients and ready in 25 minutes. Sweet mini peppers are stuffed with cream cheese, cheddar cheese and chives, then baked just until creamy!

We also love these goat cheese stuffed mini peppers, cream cheese stuffed jalapeno peppers and cream cheese stuffed mushrooms. Everything is more fun bite sized!

Fill them up, bake in the oven, and watch these cream cheese stuffed mini peppers disappear. Plus, it just so happen to be one of the easiest appetizers you will ever make, bam!

I am in love with the little sweet peppers you can buy in a bag at the store. They are not only delicious but nutritious too, loaded with vitamins and minerals.

Slice them for salads, dip them in hummus, make roasted mini sweet peppers, use them in dinner recipes, or make a stuffed sweet peppers recipe filled with cheesy goodness.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• Easy recipe: Only 6 ingredients and they are ready in 25 minutes!
• Perfect appetizer: It’s a great appetizer to serve year round at summertime BBQs, football games, or the holidays.
• Versatile serving: Serve hot or cold.
• Crowd pleasing: Just like jalapeno poppers, everyone loves these mini peppers… because cheese and perfect finger foods!
• Diet friendly: It’s naturally gluten-free, vegetarian, low carb friendly and easy to adapt to ingredients you have on hand.
• Make ahead: Prep now and bake later for easy entertaining at your next party!

Ingredients for Stuffed Mini Peppers

To make stuffed mini sweet peppers recipe you will need only 6 simple ingredients. Amounts noted here are enough for a dozen of servings or 24 halves. So feel free to half the recipe or double it depending on your needs.

• Mini sweet peppers: You will need 1 pound of mini bell peppers which is a dozen. Bags of small peppers can be purchased at the grocery store often near the regular bell peppers. If it comes in less than 1 pound, grab 2 bags. Often it comes in 1.5 pounds bag. In this case, just stuff each pepper with less filling. It will be enough, I tried.
• Cream cheese: You will need plain cream cheese, from a block or a tub. You will have to use room temperature cream cheese. If you would like to use goat cheese, just check my goat cheese stuffed mini peppers.
• Sharp cheddar cheese: Freshly grated cheddar cheese will melt and taste better. Other types of cheese like pepper jack cheese, monterey jack, mozzarella cheese or Parmesan cheese can be used too.
• Chives: Other fresh herbs like green onions and fresh parsley work as well.
• Salt and ground black pepper: To season and taste.

How to Make Cream Cheese Stuffed Mini Peppers

This recipe for stuffed mini peppers with cream cheese comes together in 25 minutes with only one bowl, one spoon and a baking tray. No mixer or extra prep is required!

To start, line two large baking sheets with parchment paper and preheat your oven to 425 degrees F.

1. Combine your filling ingredients: Add your softened cream cheese, shredded cheddar cheese, chives, salt and pepper to a medium bowl. Stir gently until thoroughly mixed. You could use an electric mixer if preferred.
2. Stuff your peppers: Cut peppers in half and stuff each pepper half with the cream cheese mixture, dividing it evenly among the peppers. Filling will not be overflowing or mounding over your peppers.
3. Bake: Place mini stuffed peppers cheese side up in a single layer on your sheet pans and bake for 15 minutes.
4. Garnish and serve: Transfer to a platter, garnish with more chives, if desired, and serve warm.

Tips for Best Results

• Line baking sheet with parchment paper: It helps with easy clean up if some filling happens to leak out.
• To remove seeds from peppers: Using a paring knife, cut them lengthwise and then cut out the white membrane inside. Seeds should come out with it easily. If a few are left, tap the pepper cut side on a cutting board to clean out completely.
• Softened cream cheese: Room temperature cream cheese is easier to mix with the other ingredients and stuff into the pepper than cold cream cheese. To soften cream cheese, just place it in a microwave for a few seconds or leave on the counter for 30 minutes to an hour.
• Lay flat: Before baking, make sure your cream cheese stuffed peppers are sitting as flat as possible, so the creamy filling doesn’t leak out.
• Make ahead option: Assemble your stuffed pepper appetizer and store covered in the refrigerator. Then proceed with baking instructions when you are ready to serve them.

Variations

• Everything bagel seasoning: Sprinkle some on before roasting. Adds additional flavor and is so good.
• Zesty: Add some horseradish to your cream cheese mixture for a burst of flavor.
• Creamier: You could add some sour cream or Greek yogurt to the filling for even more creaminess.
• Other spices: The sky’s the limit with what you can add to your cream cheese filling. Try paprika, garlic powder, or onion powder for even more savory taste. If you like spicy food, add taco seasoning or cayenne pepper.
• Add protein: You can add chopped cooked bacon to your filling mixture for cheesy bacon stuffed mini peppers. Ground beef or ground sausage is delicious too, just make sure it is fully cooked before adding it.
• Serve cold: Raw stuffed mini peppers are especially great during the summertime. You do not have to bake them!

How to Store Leftovers

These are best enjoyed right away but you can store leftovers in refrigerator in an airtight container for up to 5 days. Enjoy your leftovers cold. Do not freeze them as bell peppers do not thaw well.

FAQs

More Bell Pepper Recipes to Try

• Ground chicken stuffed peppers
• Mexican stuffed peppers
• Stuffed pepper soup
• Baked chicken and peppers

More Easy Appetizer Recipes to Try

• Baked feta dip
• Parmesan mushrooms
• Stuffed mushrooms
• Smoked salmon crostini
• Crostini with goat cheese
• Mediterranean whipped feta board

Pair this hearty appetizer with something as equally creamy and filling as white chicken chili in Instant Pot.