Instant Pot Yogurt

Instant Pot Yogurt with 2 ingredients. Also how to make yogurt for healthy breakfast ideas without a yogurt button, Greek yogurt, vanilla yogurt, cream cheese and what to do with leftover whey.

Besides this Instant Pot yogurt recipe we love making Instant Pot eggs, Instant Pot oatmeal and Instant Pot egg bites in our beloved electric pressure cooker.

Homemade Instant Pot yogurt comes out just as store bought. You can strain it further into a super creamy and thick Greek yogurt and serve with fruit and berries, and healthy granola or even quinoa granola. I love a dollop served with lazy pierogi.

Then you can turn some of Greek yogurt into a cream cheese (yes!) and make Instant Pot cheesecake bites. And last step would be to make the tallest and fluffiest whole wheat buttermilk pancakes with leftover whey.

Don’t have Instant Pot yogurt setting? No worries, you can make Instant Pot yogurt recipe without a yogurt button. Also turn some into vanilla yogurt for healthy snack recipes. We’ve got it all figured out for you!

Looking for more than just making yogurt in Instant Pot? Check out my most popular collection of healthy Instant Pot recipes.

Ingredients for Instant Pot Yogurt

• 1 gallon of milk: 1%, 2% or 3.25% dairy milk.
• 1/4 cup plain yogurt with active bacterial cultures: It can be store-bought or leftover homemade yogurt. If store-bought, make sure it has no additives like thickeners etc.

How to Make Yogurt in Instant Pot

So, here is how to make yogurt in Instant Pot:

1. Heat Milk to 180 degrees F

• Add milk to Instant Pot: Pour milk into the inner pot of your electric pressure cooker. Close the lid and set pressure release valve to Venting. Press Yogurt button until display reads Boil.
• Milk will take about an hour to heat up: When it’s finished, Instant Pot will beep, turn off and display will say Yogurt.
• Make sure milk is hot: Open the lid and using a food thermometer check milk’s temperature. It should be 180 degrees F and higher.
• If milk’s temperature is not 180 degrees F: Press Saute button and give the pressure cooker 5-10 minutes to heat the milk further. Check again.

2. Cool Milk to 110 degrees F

• 2 ways to cool milk: Remove inner pot with milk and let it cool down either on a counter (3-4 hours) or in a sink filled with cold water (15 minutes) until food thermometer reads 110 degrees F and lower.
• Remove the milk skin on top: It is like a thin film. If you leave it in, yogurt will have tiny lumps.

3. Add 1/4 Cup Yogurt

• Add 1/4 cup plain store bought or homemade yogurt: If you buy yogurt, make sure it is plain, active bacterial culture is on ingredients list, and yogurt has no additives like cornstarch etc. You can also use homemade yogurt from previously made Instant Pot yogurt recipe.
• Whisk yogurt and milk: When whisking, avoid touching the bottom of the pot to disturbing some stuck on milk during boiling.

4. Let Yogurt Incubate

• Place yogurt in Instant Pot: Place inner pot with mixture inside Instant Pot, close the lid and leave pressure release valve in either Sealing or Venting position. Doesn’t matter as Instant Pot will not come to pressure.
• Let yogurt incubate for 10 hours: Press Yogurt button until time counter is displayed and adjust time to 10 hours with + or – buttons. After 10 hours, Instant Pot will shut off.
• Check if yogurt is ready: Insert spoon in the yogurt and if it’s standing, your yogurt is almost ready.

5. Chill and Store!

• Refrigerate for 6 hours: Remove only inner pot with a batch of yogurt. Chill in the fridge for 6 hours or overnight.
• Store: Whisk after chilling, divide between glass jars and store for up to 10 days. Or make Greek yogurt, vanilla yogurt, cream cheese and pancakes with leftover whey (see below).

FAQs

More Tips

• Do not use any kind of flavored yogurt. Recipe will not work.
• Freeze 1/4 cup freshly made yogurt as a starter for next time. In case you are not planning to make yogurt again soon.
• Freeze leftovers. Readers have reported successfully freezing and thawing yogurt. It will look lumpy but once you stir it, it will become smooth.

How to Make Yogurt without Yogurt Setting

Timing is everything with this method.

1. Heat up milk as per recipe: In an Instant Pot without yogurt setting (button), add milk, close the lid and set pressure release valve to Venting. Press Saute and heat up milk to 180 degrees F or higher. Open the lid and check with a food thermometer periodically.
2. Cool off boiled milk in a sink – do step 3 at same time: While milk is heating up, fill up sink with cold water enough to reach almost the top of the Instant Pot insert. Remove inner pot with milk, place in a sink and let milk cool until food thermometer reads 110 F and lower. Takes about 15 minutes. Don’t walk away.
3. Keep Instant Pot warm – do step 2 at same time: While milk is cooling off, press Cancel on Instant Pot and keep lid on to keep it warm. It will become an incubator for yogurt.
4. Add yogurt starter: Move pot from the sink to the counter. Remove milk skin on top and add store-bought yogurt. Whisk to combine without touching the bottom (disturbing sticky milk).
5. Let yogurt incubate for 10 hours or overnight: Place inner pot inside Instant Pot, close with the lid, wrap it in large beach towel and leave on a counter overnight or for 10 hours. Instant Pot should be off and milk still lukewarm, that will ensure proper incubation and favourable environment for live cultures to grow.

How to Make Greek Yogurt and Vanilla Yogurt

Instant Pot Greek Yogurt

• Prep: Line large mesh strainer with cheesecloth folded 4 times or single layer of coffee filters. Place on top of a bowl making sure there is enough space for draining the whey.
• Strain for 4 hours: Add desired amount of yogurt, place in the fridge and strain for 4 hours.
• Stir and enjoy: Greek style yogurt will be thicker along the walls. Just stir after adding to a jar. We love-love making my mom’s strawberry yogurt with Greek yogurt instead of sour cream for a healthier alternative.

How to Make Cream Cheese

Cream cheese is simply strained Greek yogurt for longer amount of time.

• Strain overnight: Follow instructions for Greek yogurt above and strain desired amount overnight in the fridge.
• Add salt: Then transfer to a glass container and mix with a pinch of salt.
• Storing: Refrigerate for up to 2 weeks.

How to Make Vanilla Yogurt

Whisk 1 cup of finished regular or Greek yogurt with 2 tbsp maple syrup or honey and 1 tsp pure vanilla extract. Adjust to taste and store like other yogurt.

Use Yogurt in These Recipes

• Strawberry yogurt – the best 5 minute healthy dessert EVER!
• Greek yogurt guacamole – guacamole with a protein punch and tang.
• Tartar sauce – so good and guilt free with seafood.
• Avocado Greek yogurt dip – with spicy buffalo hot sauce.
• Healthy spinach dip – as creamy as the classic without loads of mayo.

Include yogurt on your brunch charcuterie board for guests to DIY their own yogurt parfaits with healthy fruit salad and healthy granola!

More Favorite Recipes

• Instant Pot applesauce
• Chia pudding
• Instant Pot poached eggs
• Instant Pot steel cut oats
• Vegan vanilla ice cream
• Need more ideas for your pressure cooker? Browse all healthy Instant Pot recipes.